Appeals court rejects monkey selfie copyright suit

Appeals court rejects monkey selfie copyright suit

Naruto - a crested macaque whose 2011 selfie was seen around the world - would be crushed to learn that a panel of federal judges in San Francisco ruled Monday that animals can't sue for the rights to intellectual property. British nature photographer David Slater set up a camera in an Indonesian forest, and Naruto somehow tripped the camera himself (Slater was not on the scene).

In 2004, the Ninth Circuit ruled that animals can sue under the U.S. Constitution-a precedent that was binding to the three-judge panel hearing this case.

PETA's 2015 suit against Slater sought financial control of the photographs - including a now-famous selfie of the monkey grinning - for the benefit of the animal named Naruto.

The court "missed the point", PETA said in a statement.

The ruling came in the case of a monkey that took selfies with a wildlife photographer's camera.

Slater was on a trip to Sulawesi, Indonesia, and argued that his company, Wildlife Personalities Ltd., owned worldwide commercial rights to the photos. But the 9th Circuit still made a decision to rule in the important case. The judge said the law reserved that power only for humans.

PETA didn't seem particularly close to Naruto even though it sued Slater as a "next friend" of the monkey, the court noted. The court ordered PETA to pay Slater's legal fees, for both the appeal and the original trial in district court.

But the court refused, saying a decision in this "developing area of the law" would help guide lower courts and considerable public resources had been spent on the case.

Under a settlement agreement reached a year ago with PETA, Slater would retain the rights to the photos, but he would donate 25 percent of future revenue derived from the images to charities that protect Naruto and other crested macaque monkeys.

Related:

Comments

Latest news

Kipchoge, Cheruiyot celebrate Kenyan double at London Marathon
In the end Weir held off the Swiss challenger by just the length of a chair to win a race that he first triumphed in 16 years ago. Meanwhile, Paula Radcliffe's world record survived as Vivian Cheruiyot timed her run to perfection to win the women's race .

Samsung shares hurt by negative Morgan Stanley forecast
The company will be starting construction soon on a special EUV facility as part of their Hwaseong complex in South Korea. The Note 8 has seen an incredible return to form for the company and saw over 4 million devices sold around the world.

Google Fire’s Guy For Memo
A memo that has brought more attention to the very critical issue that is rocking Silicon Valley and indeed the rest of the world. Should the guy dare complain, he is branded with the vilest descriptions?Rather stay at home and enjoy casinos online .

Odds and predictions for the Bayern Munich against Gunners
This season he brought 17 goals in the league matches. - Key man for Bayern is probably Robert Lewandowski this season. It will be 16 round of Champions League, and Gunners definitely hope to beat their rivals and make revenge.

Other news